Jenna, Sally, and Alex worked for several hours at the coffee house on their project about the effects of caffeine on the human body. Even though the project was almost complete by night’s end, they decided to meet in the library at seven o’clock the morning it was due to proofread it and put any last minute touches on it before the nine o’clock deadline. They said their goodbyes and parted for the night, promising to meet in the morning on the day after tomorrow.
Sally was the first to arrive at the library that morning. She was a few minutes early, so she waited for the others to arrive. Alex arrived promptly at 7:00. “Good morning, Sally. Have you seen Jenna yet?” Sally replied, “No. Let’s give her a few minutes before we get started.”
Fifteen minutes passed and still no Jenna. “You know, Alex,” said Sally, “we should probably go ahead and get started. I’d hate to run out of time.” So, Sally and Alex decided to finish the project.
Finally, at 7:45, Jenna arrived. She looked like she had just rolled out of bed. Jenna grumbled a hello to her partners. As they all began to work together, both Alex and Sally immediately noticed that Jenna was cranky and difficult to work with. Compared to two nights ago, Jenna was irritable, jumpy, and unable to concentrate.
Sally asked, “Jenna, are you okay?”
Jenna replied, “No, I’m really tired. I couldn’t sleep well last night. I have a headache; I feel shaky, and I am nauseous. Maybe I am coming down with the flu or some virus.”
Sally and Alex murmured something sympathetic even though they both simply wished Jenna would snap out of it and be helpful. Sally offered Jenna medication for her headache.
Jenna mused, “You know, I haven’t felt right since we started working on this project. I thought about all of the coffee I drink, and I decided to try to go without it. Now, I am not sure it was a good idea.”
Originally published at http://www.sciencecases.org/caffeine/caffeine5.asp
Copyright © 1999–2009 by the National Center for Case Study Teaching in Science. Please see our usage guidelines, which outline our policy concerning permissible reproduction of this work.