Hot wine

The Hot Tub Mystery:
The Story of a Very HOT Tub

by
Herbert House
Biology Department
Elon University, Elon, NC


Part I—The Discovery

Cast of Characters

Friday, 7pm

Roma and Clint Underhill had both had a long day. They were the owners of a successful real estate company in Desert Palm. Each had several clients, and the strain of the current real estate market was getting to them. It had been an unusually cool day for January, with temperatures hovering around 60 degrees. On coming home they decided to relax in their hot tub with some wine. While Roma changed from her work clothes, Clint said that he would join her in the hot tub after he took his Lasix.

Saturday, 8am

“911… Please state your emergency.”

“Oh, Oh, I… I… ”

“Ma’am, please calm down and tell me the address.”

“I think…, yes, OK, it’s… it’s 2560 Oak Creek Drive.”

“What is the problem, please?”

“I’m the maid for Mr. and Mrs. Underhill and… and I didn’t find them in the house when I came in this morning, so I looked around outside. I just found them in their hot tub out back. They are under the water. Please come, please come now!”

“Yes, ma’am, I’m alerting the EMTs and an ambulance will be on the way. Please go out front and wait, so the paramedics can find the address quickly.”

Saturday, 8:10am

Paramedics Kavita Dickson and Larry Gonzales brought the ambulance to a stop at the end of a long driveway next to an impressive two-story mansion. The maid was on the front steps and quickly directed them to the back patio where the hot tub could be seen.

Empty bottles of wine were on the ledge surrounding the hot tub. Kavita quickly climbed up the steps and saw the bodies of the Underhills on the bottom of the hot tub. As she got into the water, she exclaimed, “This water seems really hot. Let’s see if we can get them out.” Larry climbed in after her and together they dragged the bodies out of the hot tub and onto the patio. It was obvious that both had been dead for some time. Kavita called the dispatcher.

“Listen, Linda, this hot tub case is a DOA, but something is not right. How about sending the medical examiner and a detective out to look the situation over. Tell them to bring a thermometer!”

Questions

  1. What observations did the paramedics make?
  2. List the questions raised about this situation or that you think that the investigators should ask of the maid.
  3. List any physiological effects that you think would be associated with this situation.
  4. How might these physiological effects have contributed to the Underhills’ death?
  5. Make an initial speculation about the cause of the Underhills’ death.

Go to Part II—“The Investigation”

Date Posted: 01/17/05 nas

This file is also available in Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF).  PDF Version

Originally published at http://www.sciencecases.org/blood_pressure/blood_pressure.asp

Copyright © 1999–2010 by the National Center for Case Study Teaching in Science.  Please see our usage guidelines, which outline our policy concerning permissible reproduction of this work.